I think you may be underestimating the carrying capability of a vehicle like ours (mine).
For example: my Land Cruiser has a 4" lift with 33" tires. With the roof on it is just about as tall as my van is right now. Then add the rack on which is another 9-10" and take into consideration the track width on the FJ40 74" and my van is 81". The rack for the FJ40 is so heavy empty I can barely lift it (it has a 1/4" thick tread plate floor). The FJ40 is also 2/3 the length of my van and the rack is only 5' X 5.5' square and clamped to a rain gutter.
200# ain't shizzle for a load. I have had upwards of 600# of my FJ40 rack and drove around just fine, albeit very carefully. During a hunting trip up to the Oregon / Washington area we hauled several hundred pounds of gear on the roof across gnarly terrain, mostly volcanic pyroclastic rock (like razorblades on your tires). The rack carried the load there and back to CA with no issues.
Now enter my van. Wider track width and much longer wheelbase, similar in height, soon to have an even beefier suspension and a much larger yet lighter weight rack.
Right now I have no problem lifting it and this is about 2/3 of the total weight that's going on the roof:
I think it will be just fine. If not, it takes only 8 bolts to remove the basket and I still have rack rails on the roof to attach stuff to.
I can do aluminum with my MIG. Like i said before, if you wanted a rack that would be as capable as this one you would need materials with a wall thickness of at least 1/8" and you would not be able to use the porthole plates as load bearing supports. You would need to weld tubing or pipe in. I suppose if you just want the sides to keep junk from flying off like a basket then maybe you could weld 1/8" or 3/16" thick aluminum plates to the sides for support. The floor cross members would have to be very thick material if you ever planned to walk around on it or sleep several people on the roof.
I might make an aluminum version someday. I know it will probably cost 3X as much in materials. Just the welding wire alone costs nearly double.
I am going to do a ladder on the door like the photo showed at the beginning of this thread. I might also add a hatch door in the roof so I can pop up like a Jack-in-the-Box and shoot, throw poo, cuss and get up top quickly to bare my fat smelly ass at anyone I don't like.
![Nasty :butthead:](./images/smilies/icon_butt.gif)
The 50cal. is just a back-up. I'll have lasers in the headlamps and an EMP device on the front of the rack.